Tag Archives: trump

Brazil’s Odebrecht Continues Corrupting the Judicial Process to Evade Restitution

29 Oct

Norberto Odebrecht was founded in Brazil in 1944, and gradually expanded to become an international civil engineering giant. Then, in 2016, it signed a global leniency agreement in Brazil and pled guilty in the U.S. federal court to systemic bribery committed between 2001-16 and paid billions in criminal fines. In 2006, Odebrecht had institutionalized their bribing operations by running them through a new Division of Structured Operations. During the years investigated, Odebrecht had paid around $788 million in verified bribes to secure more than 100 large-scale projects across 12 countries, including the 2016 Olympic Games projects in Brazil, pipelines, and transit.

A year after Odebrecht pled guilty, in 2017, a civil lawsuit was filed in the Southern District of New York by claiming to be securities defrauded investor Washington State Investment Board (WSIB) over its $100 million loss in bonds. It faced an obstacle in 2020, when Judge Paul G. Gardephe dismissed a part of WSIB’s initial complaint because WSIB had not provided details on which financial statements were distorted by bribe amounts. In 2021, a second major civil lawsuit that had been brought by investor DoubleLine was obstructed by the granting of an order shielding Odebrecht’s communications from private investigators, seemingly to protect active foreign investigations. Then, in a 2023, amended complaint, WSIB fixed the glitch that previously derailed them by linking $280 million in bribes to specific distorted corporate assets: this finally convinced Judge Gardephe to lift his discovery stay and to allow WSIB to demand corporate records. Then, WSIB attempted to ask for a summary judgement based on the criminal finding of fraud, but Magistrate Judge Barbara Moses rejected this idea and asked them to litigate the case anew civilly. While the court had allowed litigants to begin asking for discovery years earlier, Odebrecht had not been complying with these requests, and in September 2026, it attempted to formally block all discovery by claiming Brazil’s Supreme Court had dismissed their leniency agreement due to prosecutorial misconduct.

In the latest development in WSIB v. Odebrecht S.A., Judge Moses ruled against Odebrecht, arguing Brazilian squabbles cannot be employed to prevent American civil discovery. The court is now deciding if the parties will proceed by Odebrecht actually opening themselves to discovery scrutiny, or if they will begin settlement negotiations.

It has been a decade since Odebrecht confessed and opened their files to Brazilian prosecutors, and yet after a decade of attempts from investors to be compensated they have not been able to begin a case because the “details” of how Odebrecht was defrauding them is hidden in he files Odebrecht is refusing to turn over. Without access to the evidence, the prosecutors cannot prove the thing they know the evidence would logically state, based on what the criminal pleading indicates.

Only now is the U.S. court even beginning to rule on the irrationality of Odebrecht’s objections: Brazilian law cannot bar them from disclosing the facts of their briberies. Their leniency agreement was designed to protect the criminal Brazilian investigators, not the books that prove the corruption of executives, operators or investors of Odebrecht. The change that prompted this sudden renewal of litigation activities is that the Brazilian Operation Carwash has concluded back in 2021 (after 278 convictions and the recovery of $800 million), and these investigators have made public the facts in the accounts recording the briberies, and their depositions about them (released back in 2017). Thus, records are now public, even if Odebrecht continues refusing to surrender these records. The reason for a decade-long stall is partially clarified by the finding of illegal collusion between Chief Judge Sergio Moro and the prosecutors in Operation Carwash in Brazil, which have led to the Brazilian Supreme Court’s annulling of most of this operations convictions and fines due to misconduct. These absurdly stumbling trials are themselves evidence of Odebrecht’s ongoing successes at corrupting the criminal and civil judicial processes. Odebrecht is still an active company, with annual revenues that have dropped to around a billion from a peak of $30 billion pre-scandal. It is the vulture investors who anticipated Odebrecht’s “sudden” or artificially orchestrated legal collapse in 2016 who made a lot of money, and it might be their accounts that Odebrecht has been fighting to protect from implication. They also made a windfall when the Supreme Court refunded Odebrecht’s apparently temporary corruption fines.

This case proves that following-the-money is not possible without hacks when the sued party corrupts the system into blocking the legal opening of their books. And in such cases of billions-worth-in-corruption, there are no good guys. Even the 2019 Intercept uncovering of messages between Carwash prosecutors and Judge Moro showing a coordination of strategies served to reverse the criminal findings, instead of bringing new charges against the exposed judge and prosecutors. Perhaps, anti-corruption investigations are doomed to be corrupted? Who can resist bribes with billions on-offer? Across the decades the bribery and the failed lawsuits have been happening the Workers’ Party has been mostly in charge. Luiz da Silva, who just won a fourth term in October 2026, was the president between 2003-10, followed by Workers’ Party’s Dilma Rousseff (2011-6), before Rousseff was impeached and removed from office. Operation Carwash’s prosecutors had argued that the Workers’ Party was running the pay-to-play ring that Odebrecht was merely a player in. There was a claim that Lula secretly owned a house that Odebrecht and another construction company had spent over $200,000 remodeling, among other “gifts”. These accusations convinced Judge Moro to convict Lula of corruption and money laundering, for which he spent 580 days in federal prison. The 2019 Intercept leak found evidence against Judge Moro and annulled Lula’s conviction. This is why Lula could run for office yet again, and has just won. And Lula has been crushing his opponents through the courts, including convicting Jair Bolsonaro of attempting a coup d’etat for plotting a violent overthrow to overturn his failed 2022 election run. And immediately after Senator Flavio Bolsonaro lost the most recent 2026 election Lula targeted him with multiple criminal investigations over money laundering (via links to a sports-betting corporation), raising money from a financier for a film about his father, and securing campaign financing from U.S. conservative donors. And now Flavio has illegally (despite his passport being seized in Brazil) escaped into the U.S., where he has been granted visas by Trump. There are no good guys in this story, but it is a dramatic and captivating saga.

Suggested Citation:
Faktorovich, Anna. “Brazil’s Odebrecht Continues Corrupting the Judicial Process to Evade Restitution.” Anaphora’s Law Review (October 29, 2026).

A First Win for Activists Challenging DOJ’s Right to Investigate Non-Criminals

27 Oct

The Oregon Court of Appeals has reversed a trial court’s dismissal of Farrell-Smith v. Oregon Department of Justice. The plaintiffs are suing the Oregon Department of Justice (ODOJ), the Attorney General, and the Chief Counsel of ODOJ’s Criminal Justice Division over their questionable authority to operate a domestic intelligence unit called the Oregon TITAN Fusion Center: Terrorism Information Threat Analysis Network. This is one of many nationwide intelligence hubs developed by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security to assess or anticipate threats post-9/11. The plaintiffs allege that TITAN surveils politicians and activists based on their views, instead of on any suspected criminality: and this is outside TITAN’s executive mandate.

Plaintiffs have presented evidence TITAN routinely monitors activists that oppose the Jordan Cove Liquified Natural Gas Pipeline, without a “criminal nexus” for these investigations. TITAN is also improperly colluding with a private PR firm (Teneo) and a pipeline-funded sheriff’s unit to gather information while bypassing Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requirements. Privacy is also being violated when TITAN applies software to track on social media those who use the Black Lives Matter hashtag. And plaintiffs object to ODOJ’s secrecy in blocking public scrutiny and media record requests about demonstrations (i.e., Women’s March) by invoking broad “criminal intelligence” exemptions.

The trial court rejected the case partly because it interpreted the lawsuit as a request to shut down TITAN, whereas the Court of Appeals adjusted this aim to this being a challenge to the legality of TITAN’s cited operations. The case is asking: is it legal for a government agency to collect intelligence on citizens despite a lack of a suspicion of criminality? The appellate answer is that ODOJ is bound by the powers Oregon has assigned to it, or investigating: organized crime, public corruption or searching for investments of criminally implicated funds. Investigating outside these boundaries means TITAN is acting without a legal mandate. TITAN attempted to defend its actions by using loosely related laws, such as ORS 181A.250 that is inapplicable because it prohibits the collection of data based on political, religious or social views. The court rejected that obtaining a grant or a letter of acknowledgement from Governor Kitzhaber gave TITAL a special mandate.

There have been several federal lawsuits by civil liberties groups making FOIA requests to expose DHS-supported fusion centers spying on non-criminals. For example, a 2008 FOIA request revealed the Maryland Coordination and Analysis Center (MCAC) had investigated anti-death penalty and peace groups; the outcome of litigation was forcing the dismantling of the research files MCAC had gathered. And in 2025, ACLU v. Department of Justice was dismissed after a FOIA request succeeded in proving FBI’s Joint Terrorism Task Force and DHS fusion centers were investigating non-criminals by grouping radical causes with minorities and “domestic terrorism”. This Oregon case is a first state litigation that challenges the legality of such agencies to investigate non-criminals, as opposed to merely seeking FOIA data that this illegal surveillance exists. Legal scholars hope that if this Oregon case continues to see positive outcomes, it might help dismantle the 79 fusion centers across the U.S.

The lack of past accountability over these fusion centers might stem in conservatives’ successful attempts to redefine “communism”, “socialism” and other pro-justice and pro-humanist causes as amoral and thus equivalent to illegal. Mis-programmed voters tend to mis-define “communism” as totalitarianism or a lack of individual rights. They have been taught to assume there is something amoral about supporting equal rights for all, including racial and economic rights. It is in the interests of all humans to support other humans, but this re-programming turns this rational goodness into the opposite. The beneficiaries of this reversal are monopolists and pro-totalitarian rulers who prefer to limit rights: the opposite of the stated objective. Fusion centers are a present Big Brother experiment: it is an extreme form of totalitarian socialism of the Soviet variety. If DOJ’s entities are investigating non-criminals for conservatives’ political gains, they are not spending this time investigating the true criminals. Resources are being wasted to support one of two of America’s parties, while letting criminals continue criming to the detriment of us all.

Suggested Citation:
Faktorovich, Anna. “A First Win for Activists Challenging DOJ’s Right to Investigate Non-Criminals.” Anaphora’s Law Review (October 27, 2026).

How a “Fantastical” Claim from a “Presidential Candidate” Was Stuck in Pre-Trial for 7 Years Before Dismissal

26 Oct

The common problem in American courts is for cases to be instantly dismissed for a lack of merit due to slight errors made by lawyers, despite their central claims being of significance to the public. The Raysor v. Safi civil lawsuit displays a less common problem: how cases truly without merit clutter the courts’ dockets and thus force judges to reject potentially more weighty disputes.

Events began in November 2017, when officer Troy Ann Safi responded to a domestic dispute in Brooklyn, New York. Ftema Raysor was beating her boyfriend with a hairbrush and biting his ear. Kings County District Attorney dropped criminal charges against Raysor during the initial arraignment process.

Two years later, in November 2019, Raysor filed a federal civil rights complaint pro se in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York. A year still later, in December 2020, she amended her case by asking for $100 million in damages, and narrowing her claims from many more to two: false arrest and excessive force by Officer Safi. These initial complaints were a standard civil rights complaint hat accused NYPD of false arrest, racial bias and physical assault. Across the following years, Raysor failed to provide discovery on the federal case, while also pursuing a state case.

Finally, on November 12, 2025, the parties submitted a draft joint pretrial order. Then, at the Pretrial on December 29, 2025, U.S. District Judge Diane Gujarati warned Raysor that the witness list she had submitted for this meeting was deficient because she had subpoenaed irrelevant high-profile figures: Donald Trump, a former First Lady, Barack Obama, NYC Mayor Eric Adams, Reverend Al Sharpton and U.S. Senator Markwayne Mullin. At the January 20, 2026 meeting, Raysor’s filing remained noncompliant. So, on February 18, the judge refused to schedule a trial date until Raysor amended her witness list, and the case was referred to court mediation. On June 11, the parties held a video mediation settlement conference before a federal magistrate judge, but failed to reach an agreement. The judge issued another pretrial order on June 18 for Raysor to fix her filing, which she again refused at a July 8 hearing. Finally, on July 21, the city filed a motion to dismiss.

But the case was not immediately dismissed, and instead escalated on August 12-14 when Raysor submitted what the court termed “fantastical” filings that claimed her life was in danger.  In this submission, Raysor explained why she was still insisting on subpoenaing high-profile individuals by stating: “I am running for President of United States of America and was when this event took place my witness are relevant.” She insisted she was refusing “to sit back and let the Law Department kill me.” She refused to cite “cases” because “this is a matter of life or death.” In parallel with these increasingly alarming to the defendants claims, she also set up a protest tent and began living outside the federal courthouse, and began posting photographs and alleged threats against the defense lawyers on YouTube and Instagram. She apparently did indeed register to run as an independent for president in the 2028 election: and this was partly what she was documenting on her social media.

Only after this breakdown—and not immediately afterwards but two weeks later—did Judge Gujarati finally dismiss this lawsuit with prejudice (i.e., without a right to appeal). Did the slowness of the American judicial system drive this filer mad, or did it drive her to the rational solution that instead of subpoenaing presidents she had to run for president to finally obtain some justice? Was she delusional at any point, or is this a woman who succeeded in manipulating judges to keep her case on their docket for a decade? Why was she given such extraordinary number of chances to amend her complaint? Plenty of pro se and public-defender litigants have rational claims rejected on technicalities. This case many lessons to teach us all. But these lessons are too mysterious for a law class.

Suggested Citation:
Faktorovich, Anna. “How a ‘Fantastical’ Claim from a ‘Presidential Candidate’ Was Stuck in Pre-Trial for 7 Years Before Dismissal.” Anaphora’s Law Review (October 26, 2026).

Federal RICO Oversight of Teamsters Set to End

26 Oct

The latest decision in U.S.A. v. International Brotherhood of Teamsters, et al., U.S. District Judge Loretta A. Preska formally transitions the International Brotherhood of Teamsters (IBT) away from the preceding independent, court-ordered oversight and with a plan to return disciplinary control back to the union. Federal oversight commenced with a RICO lawsuit against IBT that established a consent decree in 1989. These restrictions began to be loosened in 2015 when the government seized direct involvement and put in place an outside oversight system. This 2026 order designs a plan to end oversight, claiming IBT is now free of mob corruption by having built a lasting democratically voting organization.

IBT has around 1.3 million active members across US and Canada, mostly in the delivery (UPS), transport (school buses), warehousing (Costco), civil service, airlines, railroads and food processing (Sysco) sectors.

There are now anti-mob injunctions, wherein IBT members must agree to avoid associating with a long list of barred individuals, such as La Cosa Nostra. The plan specifies that the role of the external Independent Investigations Officer (IIO) will be terminated on December 31, 2026, when their functions will transfer to IBT’s internal Office of Compliance Standards and Investigations (OCSI). Though federal judge Barbara S. Jones has been appointed to one more final three-year term as the Independent Review Officer (IRO) to oversee if the union is continuing to obey by anti-corruption mandates. And even after this three-year transition, IBT will continue to be overseen by an outside attorney with the title Independent Compliance Professional (ICP), who will sit on IBT’s Audit Committee.

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has had an interventionalist strategy against unions since the 80s. Aside for IBT, four other unions have been the subjects of federal lawsuits that have led to consent decreases for monitoring or government takeovers: International Longshoremen’s Association (ILA), Laborers’ International Union of North America (LIUNA), United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) and United Slate, Tile and Composition Roofers. Most of these oversight programs are coming to an end. In related litigation over IBT, there has been recent dissolution in Chicago, after 40 years of oversight, of Teamsters Central States Pension Fund. These attacks on the unions contributed to lowering the overall union membership rates in the US from around 18% in 1985 to 10% in 2025 (CEPR). Though a similar trend is seen internationally, as OECD reports developed nations’ union rates have dropped from 30% in 1985 to 15% in 2023. America is more sharply falling behind on collective bargaining coverage, as workers covered by collective agreements have fallen from 47% (1985) to 33.6% (2024), but in the US this number is down to 11.3%. There have been some similar to the US anti-corruption lawsuits elsewhere that have also installed government-overseers in unions, as with Australia’s compulsory state administration over its construction union CFMEU, and Canada’s trusteeship over its construction unions.

Union membership fees have increased in part to support the millions the federal government has been charging unions for their oversight. Though beyond these RICO litigations that have framed unions as corrupt, there have also been decisions such as Janus v. AFSCME at the Supreme Court that struck down mandatory agency fees for public employees that instantly halved memberships in public-sector unions.

There have been a few other non-governmental entities that have faced similar RICO scrutiny. In 2015, the football FIFA association was indicted by DOJ over accepting over $150 million in bribes to decide who would host its future championship. DOJ then placed its own monitor to oversee its operations to avoid similar corruption in the future. And DOJ filed RICO charges against SAC Capital Advisors ($14 billion in assets), thus forcing it to restructure and pay for a court-appointed compliance monitor in addition to paying $1.8 billion settlement. Back during Trump’s one failed presidential run, IBT’s General President Sean M. O’Brien made the then strange step of being the first Teamsters president ever to address the Republican National Convention (RNC). While O’Brien did not endorse Trump and focused his speech on corporate greed, by breaking the union’s prior exclusive relationship with the Democratic party (as by hosting events with Trump at Mar-a-Lago) O’Brien ingratiated himself to Trump’s administration sufficiently for the current continuation of the shift to liberate IBT from oversight.

Suggested Citation:
Faktorovich, Anna. “Federal RICO Oversight of Teamsters Set to End.” Anaphora’s Law Review (October 26, 2026).